Cardinals beat Padres 8-5 on Aug 2, 2025, with clutch hits from Pagés & Winn. But does this comeback win matter after the front office's trade deadline sell-off?
StatPro MLB Beat Reporter
For a few glorious hours on Saturday night, it felt like old times. Down 4-0, the St. Louis Cardinals clawed their way back, snapping a four-game skid with a gutsy 8-5 win over the streaking San Diego Padres. It was a night of clutch hits and youthful energy. But as the cheers fade, the harsh reality of August baseball in St. Louis sets in: this season is no longer about winning now, but about building for a distant tomorrow.
They 'Threw in the Towel.' That's the blunt assessment from around the league after the Cardinals' trade deadline sell-off.
The Cardinals looked dead in the water, trailing the Padres 4-0 and staring down a fifth straight loss. Then, the kids took over. Pedro Pagés blasted a game-tying, three-run homer—his seventh of the year—to breathe life back into Busch Stadium. The rally was capped by Masyn Winn's go-ahead two-run double, a laser that showcased the shortstop's star potential. Iván Herrera was a force all night, racking up three hits. With the bullpen thinned by trades, JoJo Romero stepped up to lock down the final four outs for his first save of the season. It was a powerful reminder of the talent already in the big leagues, fighting to prove they belong.
While the players were fighting on the field, the front office's strategy was one of surrender for 2025. In the days leading up to the trade deadline, President of Baseball Operations John Mozeliak dismantled the bullpen, shipping closer Ryan Helsley and setup man Phil Maton out of town, along with starter Steven Matz. The return was a haul of six prospects, headlined by power-hitting shortstop Jesus Baez and righty Nate Dohm. It was a clear signal: the Cardinals, 11 games back in the division, are officially in a rebuild. Mozeliak's final major act before handing the reins to Chaim Bloom was to tear it down and restock the farm system.
The win pushed the Cardinals back to .500 at 56-56, a record that now feels strangely irrelevant. The playoff chase is a fantasy. So what's the goal for the final two months? Saturday's game gave us the answer: development. We're watching to see if Masyn Winn can be the long-term answer at short. We're watching to see if Iván Herrera and Pedro Pagés can handle a bigger load. We're watching to see who from the pitching staff can carve out a role for 2026. Every game is now an audition, a data point for Chaim Bloom and the future of this franchise. The wins are fun, but the individual performances are what truly matter now.
Today's rubber match against the Padres, with Andre Pallante on the mound, is the next test. A series win against a contender would feel great, but the context has irrevocably changed. We're no longer just fans of the St. Louis Cardinals; we're scouts, watching for the building blocks of the next great Redbird team. The present may be murky, but Saturday's comeback proved the future might just be fun to watch.
