The Cardinals' 10-1 loss to the Diamondbacks on July 19, 2025, may force a trade deadline sale. Will St. Louis trade stars like Ryan Helsley?
StatPro MLB Beat Reporter
It's more than just a single game. Saturday's humiliating 10-1 defeat at the hands of the Arizona Diamondbacks felt like a tipping point for the 2025 St. Louis Cardinals. As the team sits at 51-48, three games out of a Wild Card spot and mired in a prolonged slump, the writing on the wall is becoming clear: it's time to sell.
Since the start of June, the Cardinals are 18-23 with a bottom-eight offense and a pitching staff ranked 24th in ERA.
One blowout loss can be an anomaly, but the Cardinals' recent performance is a trend. The team has been treading water, going 15-15 in their last 30 games, but the underlying numbers paint a grim picture. Since June began, the club has played well below .500 baseball (18-23). The offense has vanished, ranking in the bottom eight of the majors in nearly every significant category, while the pitching staff has posted an abysmal 24th-ranked ERA over the same stretch. Yesterday's 10-1 drubbing wasn't just a loss; it was a confirmation of the team's deepest flaws.
With the team's trajectory pointing downward, front office discussions have pivoted from buying to selling. All eyes are on the team's most valuable, controllable assets. Closer Ryan Helsley is a prime candidate, as are reliable bullpen arms like Phil Maton. Even starter Steven Matz, despite his contract, could be on the move if the Cardinals decide to eat some salary to maximize their return. The goal is no longer a desperate push for a 2025 playoff spot, but rather to reload for a more competitive future.
If the Cardinals do become sellers, the focus immediately shifts to the farm system. A recent organizational deep dive suggests a long-term plan is already taking shape under new executive Chaim Bloom. While there are concerns about pitching development, there is promise in position players like speedster Victor Scott II and the recently drafted JJ Wetherholt, who looks poised to become the third baseman of the future. Selling off current assets for more prospects would align perfectly with Bloom's strengths and accelerate this necessary rebuild.
As the Cardinals prepare for today's game against the Diamondbacks, the result on the scoreboard feels secondary. The real games are being played in the front office. Every pitch from Helsley, Maton, or Matz could be their last in a Cardinals uniform. The coming days will test the organization's nerve and reveal its true plan for returning to contention, not just in 2025, but beyond.
