The Mets defeated the Yankees 6-2 on July 4, 2025, as Pete Alonso's homer helped knock the Bombers from first place. Aaron Judge tied a record in the loss.
StatPro MLB Beat Reporter
The Fourth of July fireworks at Yankee Stadium felt more like a dud than a celebration. The Yankees kicked off the Subway Series with a dispiriting 6-2 loss to the crosstown rival Mets, a defeat that not only stung with bragging rights on the line but also knocked them out of first place in the AL East for the first time in weeks.
In just half a season, Aaron Judge has drawn 23 intentional walks, tying Mickey Mantle’s single-season franchise record set back in 1957.
The holiday showdown started with promise but quickly soured. Starter Marcus Stroman couldn't contain the Mets' bats, surrendering four runs over five innings. The back-breaking blow came in the third inning from a familiar foe, Pete Alonso, whose three-run homer silenced the Bronx crowd. The Yankees' high-powered offense was uncharacteristically quiet, managing just a handful of hits from stars like Aaron Judge and Juan Soto but failing to deliver with runners in scoring position. Reliever Caleb Ferguson allowed two more runs in the seventh, sealing a 6-2 defeat that handed the series opener and AL East lead to the Toronto Blue Jays.
Adding to the sting of the loss is a growing concern in the starting rotation. The team announced that right-hander Clarke Schmidt will undergo an MRI on his right forearm after exiting his last start against Toronto with tightness. For a pitcher who has already undergone Tommy John surgery, any issue with that arm raises immediate red flags. The Yankees are holding their breath, awaiting imaging results that will determine the severity of the injury and how long they might be without a key piece of their rotation.
Even in a tough week, there were glimmers of hope. 'The Martian,' Jasson Domínguez, looked every bit the future star with a four-hit performance in Thursday's series finale against the Blue Jays. Meanwhile, Trent Grisham made an immediate impact upon his return from a hamstring issue, launching his 16th home run of the season. But the most historic note belongs to the captain. In that same game, Aaron Judge was intentionally walked for the 23rd time this season, officially tying Mickey Mantle's 1957 franchise record—a testament to the immense fear he strikes in opposing dugouts.
While the big-league club navigates a difficult stretch, the future continues to look bright. Top outfield prospect Spencer Jones was recently promoted to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, putting him one step away from the Bronx. He'll be joined at the upcoming All-Star Futures Game by the organization's new No. 1 prospect, shortstop George Lombard Jr., offering fans a tantalizing glimpse of the next wave of Yankee talent.
Losing on a holiday to your rival is never fun, especially when it costs you first place. The Yankees now face a crucial test: can they shake off this loss and reclaim the series, or will this be the start of a mid-summer slide? With the Blue Jays breathing down their necks and the health of a key starter in question, the Bombers need to find their firepower—and fast. All eyes will be on the MRI results for Clarke Schmidt and the lineup's response in tomorrow's game.
