Pacers fall to Thunder 120-109 in Game 5 of the 2025 NBA Finals as a hobbled Tyrese Haliburton struggles. Can Indiana stave off elimination at home?
StatPro NBA Beat Reporter
The dream feels like it's hanging by a thread. In a devastating turn of events, the Indiana Pacers not only dropped a pivotal Game 5 of the NBA Finals to the Oklahoma City Thunder, 120-109, but they also watched their franchise player, Tyrese Haliburton, become a ghost of himself due to a lingering leg injury. Now, down 3-2 and facing elimination, the Pacers return to Indianapolis with more questions than answers and their championship hopes on life support.
He's not 100%.
The collective gasp from Pacers fans could be felt all the way from Oklahoma City. After just 10 minutes of play, Tyrese Haliburton limped to the locker room, his nagging leg injury clearly resurfacing at the worst possible moment. He returned with a heavy wrap on his lower right leg, but his explosiveness was gone. For the first time in his 36-game playoff career, Haliburton went scoreless in the first half. He finished the night with just 4 points and 6 assists, a shadow of the All-NBA talent who got them here. Coach Rick Carlisle's post-game confirmation was grim and direct: 'He's not 100%.' Without their floor general at full strength, the Pacers' offense sputtered at critical moments.
Even with Haliburton hampered, the Pacers fought with the heart that has defined their season. Pascal Siakam was a force, pouring in 28 points on efficient 9-of-15 shooting while adding 6 rebounds and 5 assists. Then there was T.J. McConnell, who single-handedly dragged Indiana back into the game with a third-quarter explosion, scoring 13 of his 18 points in a flurry that cut a massive 18-point deficit down to just two in the fourth. But the Thunder's star power was simply too much. Jalen Williams erupted for a career playoff-high 40 points, and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander was his usual MVP-caliber self with 31 points and 10 assists, hitting clutch shots to slam the door on Indiana's comeback.
The math is simple and brutal: win or go home. The series shifts back to Gainbridge Fieldhouse for Game 6, where the Pacers must secure a victory to force a decisive Game 7. History is not on their side, as teams winning Game 5 in a 2-2 Finals series have gone on to win the championship 74% of the time. But this Pacers team has defied expectations all year. To do it one more time, they'll need to find a way to contain OKC's dynamic duo and hope that the energy of the home crowd can work some magic for a limited Tyrese Haliburton.
The season comes down to this. One game at home to save the dream. The odds are stacked against them, and the health of their superstar is a massive unknown. But if there's one thing we've learned about this Pacers team, it's that you can never count them out. Get ready, Indiana. Game 6 will be the fight of their lives.
