Cam Schlittler was the unanimous winner of the AL Cy Young Award, receiving all 30 first-place votes ahead of Dylan Cease and Parker Messick.

Cease received 22 second-place votes, with Messick receiving seven and finishing third. Drew Ramsussen got the remaining second-place vote and finished fourth, with Sonny Gray in fifth place. Closers Cade Smith and Bryan Baker got two and one fifth-place votes, respectively. Schlittler is the 13th unanimous AL Cy Young winner and the seventh Yankee to win the award. Gerrit Cole in 2023 and Roger Clemens in 2001 were the only Yankees to win since 1980.