The Cardinals defeated the injury-plagued Blue Jays 5-2 on June 9, 2025, as Paul Goldschmidt homered off José Berríos. Can Toronto overcome its losses?
StatPro MLB Beat Reporter
It was a classic case of 'one step back' on Monday night in St. Louis. The Toronto Blue Jays, riding a wave of momentum that has placed them atop the American League Wild Card standings, were grounded by the Cardinals in a 5-2 series-opening loss. While any defeat stings, this one serves as a stark reminder of the tightrope the team is walking, battling not just their opponents, but a growing list of injuries to key personnel.
Who leads the 2025 Blue Jays in Wins Above Replacement? It's not a superstar slugger, but utility infielder Ernie Clement, the embodiment of the team's 'next man up' success.
Starter José Berríos battled but couldn't contain the Cardinals' offense, surrendering four runs over 5.2 innings. The big blows came via a two-run double from Lars Nootbaar in the third and a solo shot from Paul Goldschmidt in the sixth. Toronto's bats were mostly quiet, managing just two runs on a Vladimir Guerrero Jr. RBI single and a run-scoring double from George Springer. The loss drops the Jays to 35-31, but it was a night where the offense couldn't quite overcome a tough pitching matchup on the road.
The context for the loss looms large on the injured list. The Blue Jays are navigating a critical stretch without ace Max Scherzer (thumb), outfielders Anthony Santander (shoulder) and Daulton Varsho (hamstring), and key relievers Yimi García and Nick Sandlin. This has stretched the bullpen thin and forced depth players into everyday roles, a challenge that was apparent in Monday's game.
Despite the injuries and Monday's loss, the bigger picture remains bright. The Jays entered the day having won 21 of their last 34 games, a torrid pace that has them in control of the top AL Wild Card spot. The surge has been fueled by unexpected contributors, none more so than Ernie Clement. The slick-fielding infielder has provided steady defense and timely hitting, surprisingly leading the entire team in Wins Above Replacement (WAR). This resilience is why the team has earned 4 points in the 'Summer Score' rankings, a metric tracking their momentum.
While the big-league club patches things together, the farm system offers a glimpse into the future. First-round pick Trey Yesavage is dominating at Low-A, while shortstop Arjun Nimmala is quickly ascending into a consensus top-50 prospect. There are setbacks, of course, like top pitching prospect Jake Bloss undergoing Tommy John surgery. Still, the growing depth in the minors provides hope for future waves of talent to support the major league roster.
One loss in June, even a frustrating one, doesn't define a season. The real story for the 2025 Blue Jays is their ability to weather the storm. The challenge now is to shake off the loss, find a way to manufacture runs against the Cardinals for the rest of the series, and prove their recent hot streak was more than just a flash in the pan. This team's grit will be tested, and the next few games will show us just how deep that resilience runs.
