American League
Sign in
Sign in and connect Sleeper to unlock personalized fantasy insights.
57 articles
TOR •
1 day ago
There’s probably another timeline out there in which Scherzer, not Justin Verlander, was the returning hero signed to fortify in the Tigers’ rotation over the winter, but not this one. Scherzer sort of got the better today of Tarik Skubal, who allowed one run while also getting 14 outs, but he had a little bit easier of an assignment against Detroit’s road lineup and the Tigers did end up winning anyway. Scherzer has looked really good this spring even without accounting for the fact that he only signed 12 days ago. There’s probably no way he’s giving the Blue Jays or fantasy teams six good months, but it looks like he’ll be quite valuable initially.
TOR •
8 days ago
The only run of the game came on a Jonathan Clase groundout in the ninth after Rafael Lantigua doubled and stole third. Scherzer topped out at 95.8 mph today and averaged 93.9 mph with his fastball, which was slightly up from his 2025 average of 93.3 mph. Thoughts that he might need to open the season on the IL after his late signing are gone now, so the Jays are looking at quite the crowded rotation even with Shane Bieber sidelined. A six-man rotation is possible, but Cody Ponce and José Berríos could wind up in the pen at times.
TOR •
13 days ago
Scherzer returning for a 19th season feels less like a transaction and more like a reminder that certain careers refuse to fade quietly. The deal is now official, bringing the 41-year-old future Hall of Famer back to Toronto, where he adds experienced depth to a contending rotation. The surface numbers from last season — 5.19 ERA (4.62 xERA) with a 1.29 WHIP and 82/23 K/BB ratio over 85 innings across 17 starts — were pedestrian in nature, though his postseason performance looked far more familiar. Scherzer may no longer be a relevant fantasy contributor at this stage of his legendary career, but he remains the type of presence who can bend a playoff series in subtle, consequential ways.
TOR •
4 months ago
Scherzer’s remarks came in the wake of Toronto’s heartbreaking Game 7 loss to the Dodgers, which capped one of the most thrilling Fall Classics in recent memory. The 41-year-old future Hall of Famer allowed one run over 4 1/3 innings in that contest and said afterward there’s “no way” that was his final pitch in the majors. He proved to be a true X-factor for the Blue Jays during their postseason run after injuries limited him to just 17 regular-season starts. While he’s unlikely to carry much fantasy value next year due to omnipresent physical concerns, his playoff experience, big-game moxie, and competitiveness should appeal to contenders seeking to fortify the back end of their rotation this offseason.
Source: Jesse Rogers
TOR •
4 months ago
The grizzled 41-year-old right-hander struck out three batters on the night while allowing only one base on balls. The Dodgers had him on the ropes in the fourth inning as Will Smith led off with a double and Freddie Freeman followed with a single, but he ultimately allowed just the one run on a sacrifice fly off the bat of Teoscar Hernandez on what was an outstanding diving catch by Daulton Varsho in center field. Scherzer got five whiffs on 54 pitches on the night, posting a CSW of 24%. He left with a 3-1 lead and in position to secure a World Championship with a third different ballclub, but the Dodgers rallied late and would not be denied. It remains to be seen if this is how the future Hall of Famer wants to go out, or if he has plans on pitching again in 2026.
TOR •
5 months ago
Scherzer became the first player to pitch for four teams in the Fall Classic during his career and was long gone by the time this one was eventually decided in extra innings. The 41-year-old future Hall of Famer was burned by the long ball during the early stages of this one as Teoscar Hernández and Shohei Ohtani connected for solo homers in the second and third innings, respectively. He got some help from teammate Addison Barger, who made a tremendous 98.5 mph throw to cut down Freddie Freeman at the plate to prevent any further damage and end the third.
TOR •
5 months ago
He’ll be followed by Shane Bieber in Game 4. Scherzer was brilliant in a victory over the Mariners in Game 4 of the ALDS — striking out five batters over 5 2/3 innings of two-run baseball. Depending on Saturday night’s result, he’ll either be working to give the Jays a commanding 3-0 lead in the series or pitching a pivotal battle if the series is knotted up at one game apiece.
Source: Bob Nightengale
TOR •
5 months ago
Scherzer showed zero signs of rust in his first start in over three weeks, nearly navigating six frames in his 500th career start. The 41-year-old future Hall of Famer shook off an early solo homer by Josh Naylor to keep Seattle scoreless into the middle innings. He was lifted at 87 pitches after surrendering a two-out walk to Jorge Polanco in the sixth.
TOR •
5 months ago
Scherzer will get the ball in Seattle opposite Luis Castillo for his first outing of the postseason after being left off Toronto’s ALDS roster entirely. The 41-year-old future Hall of Famer could draw the starting assignment in a potential elimination game if the Blue Jays fall in Game 3 after dropping the opening two contests of the best-of-seven series back at the Rogers Centre. It’s unlikely to be an extended outing since he hasn’t pitched in a game situation since September 24, which was three weeks ago.
Source: Arden Zwelling
TOR •
5 months ago
Toronto adds some much-needed postseason experience in the pair of veteran starters in advance of the best-of-seven showdown against Seattle. It’ll be Kevin Gausman, Trey Yesavage and Shane Bieber fronting Toronto’s rotation at the outset of the series but Scherzer and Bassitt figure to be options to take the ball as a traditional starter or come out of the bullpen in relief as it progresses.
Source: Toronto Blue Jays
TOR •
5 months ago
Schneider added that Scherzer likely would’ve been included on the roster for a matchup against the Red Sox, but they wanted to include some additional left-handed relief depth to combat New York’s plethora of lefty sluggers. It’ll likely be some combination of Eric Lauer and the bullpen working a potential Game 4 matchup with Kevin Gausman looming for a winner-take-all Game 5.
Source: Ben Nicholson-Smith
TOR •
5 months ago
Schneider added that Scherzer likely would’ve been included on the roster for a matchup against the Red Sox, but they wanted to include some additional left-handed relief depth to combat New York’s plethora of lefty sluggers. It’ll likely be some combination of Eric Lauer and the bullpen working a potential Game 4 matchup with Kevin Gausman looming for a winner-take-all Game 5.
Source: Ben Nicholson-Smith
TOR •
5 months ago
While it’s nice to see the right-hander get plenty of work in to stay sharp, it makes it highly unlikely that he’ll be used to start either the first or second game against the winner of the Red Sox and Yankees. Expect Scherzer to take the mound on the road in Game 3 or Game 4.
Source: Ben Nicholson-Smith
TOR •
6 months ago
It looked like it’d be a short night for Scherzer after a three-run first, but he rebounded from there and ended up striking out five and walking none. It’s just the 16th time in his career that Scherzer has allowed 10 hits, compared to 114 with at least 10 strikeouts. Unfortunately, the weak finish is probably going to knock him out of the Jays’ rotation plans for the postseason, though that will hinge on Chris Bassitt’s health. Scherzer posted a 9.00 ERA in his final six starts to finish up at 5-5 with a 5.19 ERA in 17 starts.
TOR •
6 months ago
Scherzer gave up seven hits, walked one and struck out two. The 41-year-old right-hander hadn’t allowed more than four runs in any of his 15 starts this year entering play Friday. Scherzer threw 45 pitches in a first inning that he couldn’t escape. He has a 5.06 ERA and 77/23 K/BB ratio in 80 innings this year. Scherzer is lined up to face the Red Sox at home next week.
TOR •
6 months ago
Shane Bieber is due to pitch Saturday, but the Jays haven’t confirmed that yet. It’s looking like Trey Yesavage will get the nod on Sunday, leading to José Berríos being pushed back or skipped.
Source: Shi Davidi
TOR •
6 months ago
A single, walk, double, and a groundout put two runs on the board for the Orioles in the first inning. Scherzer settled in to toss four more scoreless frames, ending his day with five strikeouts over five innings on 91 pitches. The 41-year-old right-hander will take a 4.31 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, and a 75/22 K/BB ratio across 79 1/3 innings into a start against the Rays in Tampa Bay on Thursday.
TOR •
6 months ago
Scherzer gave up three hits, walked four and struck out eight. The 41-year-old right-hander ran into problems in the first inning. After allowing two baserunners to reach with one out, Scherzer allowed a three-run home run to Ben Rice. He’s allowed four runs in three consecutive starts now. Scherzer is lined up to face the Orioles at home next weekend.
TOR •
6 months ago
The Jays will go with Chris Bassitt on normal rest on Saturday, giving Scherzer’s balky back an extra day to heal before he faces the Yankees. The 41-year-old right-hander holds a 4.11 ERA, 1.13 WHIP and a 62/16 K/BB ratio over 70 innings through his first 13 starts for the Jays.
Source: Rob Longley
TOR •
6 months ago
Scherzer was lifted from Sunday’s start against the Brewers after just four frames due to upper back tightness. The 41-year-old future Hall of Famer has battled a laundry list of physical issues this season in his Blue Jays debut. The encouraging update seems to signal that he’s feeling well enough to avoid another trip to the injured list.
Source: Arden Zwelling
TOR •
7 months ago
Given his injury history and age, it’s fair to be concerned about any sort of back issue cropping up for the 41-year-old hurler. Prior to exiting on Sunday, Scherzer had surrendered four runs on nine hits over his four frames while recording only one strikeout. How he feels over the next couple of days will likely impact whether or not he’s able to make his next scheduled start or if Scherzer will require a trip to the injured list.
Source: Hazel Mae
TOR •
7 months ago
Scherzer allowed only four hits, but two of them were homers by Matt Wallner. He struck out five and walked one. It’s his third straight win, moving him to 5-2 with a 3.82 ERA on the season. His 221st career victory moved him into a tie with Joe Niekro from 79th place all-time. With the Jays using a six-man rotation this week, Scherzer probably won’t pitch again until next Monday against the Reds.
TOR •
7 months ago
Scherzer has allowed five runs in four starts this month, moving him to 3-2 with a 3.60 ERA on the season. There’s no guarantee that he’ll stay healthy the rest of the way, but he’s looking like a top-30 SP with the way he’s throwing right now. He’s slated to face the Twins next week.
TOR •
7 months ago
Just 78 pitches for Scherzer today. Seeing as though he gave up a leadoff double to start the eighth in a one-run game, he might want to get Brandon Little and Seranthony Domínguez a little something for aiding his 219th career victory. Little walked Seiya Suzuki but then struck out two in a row. Domínguez came in at that point and fanned Carson Kelly to end the threat. The victory at least temporarily moves Scherzer ahead of Clayton Kershaw on the all-time list. He’s now tied with Pedro Martínez and Kenny Rogers for 81st place. Today’s start was the first in which he’s worked into the eighth since June 19, 2023, when he defeated the Astros in one of his final outings for the Mets. He’ll pitch in Pittsburgh next week.
TOR •
7 months ago
Scherzer did walk three while throwing 63-of-98 pitches for strikes, so it’s fair to say that the future Hall of Famer didn’t have his best control. He still held Los Angeles to just two runs; both coming on a Mookie Betts homer in the fifth. Scherzer has been excellent over his last three starts, and will get a chance to keep it going against the Cubs next week.
TOR •
8 months ago
Scherzer got through five quiet innings scattering four hits and no walks before giving up a solo homer to Salvador Perez in the sixth. He’d finish out the frame to end his day with five strikeouts. It was one of the better starts of the season for the 41-year-old right-hander. He’ll take a 4.39 ERA, 1.05 WHIP, and a 44/8 K/BB ratio across 41 innings into a start against the Dodgers in Los Angeles on Friday.
TOR •
8 months ago
The 41-year-old hurler allowed just three hits on the afternoon and didn’t walk a batter. Unfortunately, all three of those hits came in the third innings — the last of which was a two-out, three-run opposite-field blast off the bat of Gleyber Torres. He was perfect in each of his other six frames. Scherzer got 15 swings and misses on 96 pitches on the day — six on his slider — while posting a strong CSW of 33 percent. He’ll carry a 4.89 ERA, 1.09 WHIP and a 39/8 K/BB ratio (35 innings) into Saturday’s matchup against the Royals.
TOR •
8 months ago
Scherzer, who gave up homers to Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Cody Bellinger, left trailing 4-2, but the Jays let him off the hook in the bottom of the sixth. Scherzer finished up with four strikeouts tonight, though just eight of the 42 swings against him produced whiffs. His ERA is sitting at 5.14 with a showdown against the Tigers on deck.
TOR •
8 months ago
It took until the weekend before the All-Star break, but Scherzer finally has his first win as a member of the Blue Jays. He blanked the A’s for the first five innings, but he gave up a three-spot in the sixth to turn a very impressive outing into one that still counts as a quality start. Scherzer will take a 4.70 ERA and 24/7 K/BB over 23 innings into the second half.
TOR •
8 months ago
Scherzer’s troublesome right thumb becomes more of a factor the longer he pitches, so quick hooks like this are probably going to be the norm here. Scherzer allowed five hits, walked three and struck out four in the 72-pitch outing today. He’ll probably make his next start Friday against the A’s, unless maybe the Jays want to IL him through the All-Star break and hope that helps his thumb.