| 2025 SB LX | — | Dak Prescott 3,637 yds • Dallas Cowboys | Jonathan Taylor 1,356 yds • Indianapolis Colts | Jaxon Smith-Njigba 1,428 yds • Seattle Seahawks |
| 2024 SB LIX | Philadelphia Eagles | Jared Goff 4,942 yds • Detroit Lions | Saquon Barkley 2,504 yds • Philadelphia Eagles | Ja'Marr Chase 1,708 yds • Cincinnati Bengals |
| 2023 SB LVIII | Kansas City Chiefs | Jared Goff 5,412 yds • Detroit Lions | Christian McCaffrey 1,727 yds • San Francisco 49ers | Tyreek Hill 1,861 yds • Miami Dolphins |
| 2022 SB LVII | Kansas City Chiefs | Patrick Mahomes 5,953 yds • Kansas City Chiefs | Josh Jacobs 1,653 yds • Las Vegas Raiders | Justin Jefferson 1,856 yds • Minnesota Vikings |
| 2021 SB LVI | Los Angeles Rams | Matthew Stafford 6,074 yds • Los Angeles Rams | Jonathan Taylor 1,811 yds • Indianapolis Colts | Cooper Kupp 2,425 yds • Los Angeles Rams |
| 2020 SB LV | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Patrick Mahomes 5,590 yds • Kansas City Chiefs | Derrick Henry 2,067 yds • Tennessee Titans | Stefon Diggs 1,846 yds • Buffalo Bills |
| 2019 SB LIV | Kansas City Chiefs | Patrick Mahomes 4,932 yds • Kansas City Chiefs | Derrick Henry 1,883 yds • Tennessee Titans | Michael Thomas 1,681 yds • New Orleans Saints |
| 2018 SB LIII | New England Patriots | Patrick Mahomes 5,670 yds • Kansas City Chiefs | Ezekiel Elliott 1,618 yds • Dallas Cowboys | Julio Jones 1,677 yds • Atlanta Falcons |
| 2017 SB LII | Philadelphia Eagles | Tom Brady 5,709 yds • New England Patriots | Todd Gurley 1,406 yds • Los Angeles Rams | Antonio Brown 1,665 yds • Pittsburgh Steelers |
| 2016 SB LI | New England Patriots | Matt Ryan 5,958 yds • Atlanta Falcons | Ezekiel Elliott 1,756 yds • Dallas Cowboys | Julio Jones 1,743 yds • Atlanta Falcons |
| 2015 SB L | Denver Broncos | Tom Brady 5,382 yds • New England Patriots | Adrian Peterson 1,530 yds • Minnesota Vikings | Antonio Brown 1,953 yds • Pittsburgh Steelers |
| 2014 SB XLIX | New England Patriots | — | — | — |
| 2013 SB XLVIII | Seattle Seahawks | Peyton Manning 6,001 yds • Denver Broncos | LeSean McCoy 1,684 yds • Philadelphia Eagles | Demaryius Thomas 1,654 yds • Denver Broncos |
| 2012 SB XLVII | San Francisco 49ers | Tom Brady 5,491 yds • New England Patriots | Adrian Peterson 2,196 yds • Minnesota Vikings | Caleb Johnson 1,964 yds • Detroit Lions |
| 2011 SB XLVI | New York Giants | Drew Brees 6,404 yds • New Orleans Saints | Maurice Jones-Drew 1,606 yds • Jacksonville Jaguars | Victor Cruz 1,805 yds • New York Giants |
| 2010 SB XLV | Green Bay Packers | Drew Brees 5,024 yds • New Orleans Saints | Arian Foster 1,616 yds • Houston Texans | Greg Jennings 1,568 yds • Green Bay Packers |
| 2009 SB XLIV | New Orleans Saints | Peyton Manning 5,236 yds • Indianapolis Colts | Chris Johnson 2,006 yds • Tennessee Titans | Andre Johnson 1,569 yds • Houston Texans |
| 2008 SB XLIII | Pittsburgh Steelers | Kurt Warner 5,730 yds • Arizona Cardinals | Michael Turner 1,741 yds • Atlanta Falcons | Larry Fitzgerald 1,977 yds • Arizona Cardinals |
| 2007 SB XLII | New York Giants | Tom Brady 4,536 yds • New England Patriots | Clinton Portis 1,159 yds • Washington Commanders | Reggie Wayne 1,499 yds • Indianapolis Colts |
| 2006 SB XLI | Indianapolis Colts | Peyton Manning 5,431 yds • Indianapolis Colts | LaDainian Tomlinson 1,834 yds • Los Angeles Chargers | Marvin Harrison 1,559 yds • Indianapolis Colts |
| 2005 SB XL | Pittsburgh Steelers | Tom Brady 4,652 yds • New England Patriots | Shaun Alexander 2,116 yds • Seattle Seahawks | Steve Smith Sr. 1,898 yds • Carolina Panthers |
| 2004 SB XXXIX | Philadelphia Eagles | Daunte Culpepper 5,317 yds • Minnesota Vikings | Corey Dillon 1,927 yds • New England Patriots | Torry Holt 1,522 yds • Los Angeles Rams |
| 2003 SB XXXVIII | Carolina Panthers | Peyton Manning 5,185 yds • Indianapolis Colts | Ahman Green 2,105 yds • Green Bay Packers | Torry Holt 1,717 yds • Los Angeles Rams |
| 2002 SB XXXVII | Las Vegas Raiders | Rich Gannon 5,026 yds • Las Vegas Raiders | Ricky Williams 1,559 yds • Miami Dolphins | Marvin Harrison 1,552 yds • Indianapolis Colts |
| 2001 SB XXXVI | New England Patriots | Kurt Warner 5,302 yds • Los Angeles Rams | Marshall Faulk 1,594 yds • Los Angeles Rams | Torry Holt 1,537 yds • Los Angeles Rams |
| 2000 SB XXXV | Baltimore Ravens | Peyton Manning 4,475 yds • Indianapolis Colts | Edgerrin James 1,705 yds • Indianapolis Colts | Rod Smith 1,578 yds • Denver Broncos |
| 1999 SB XXXIV | Los Angeles Rams | — | — | — |
| 1998 SB XXXIII | Denver Broncos | — | — | — |
| 1997 SB XXXII | Denver Broncos | — | — | — |
| 1996 SB XXXI | Green Bay Packers | — | — | — |
| 1995 SB XXX | Dallas Cowboys | — | — | — |
| 1994 SB XXIX | San Francisco 49ers | — | — | — |
| 1993 SB XXVIII | Dallas Cowboys | — | — | — |
| 1992 SB XXVII | Dallas Cowboys | — | — | — |
| 1991 SB XXVI | Washington Commanders | — | — | — |
| 1990 SB XXV | New York Giants | — | — | — |
| 1989 SB XXIV | San Francisco 49ers | — | — | — |
| 1988 SB XXIII | San Francisco 49ers | — | — | — |
| 1987 SB XXII | Washington Commanders | — | — | — |
| 1986 SB XXI | New York Giants | — | — | — |
| 1985 SB XX | Chicago Bears | — | — | — |
| 1984 SB XIX | San Francisco 49ers | — | — | — |
| 1983 SB XVIII | Las Vegas Raiders | — | — | — |
| 1982 SB XVII | Washington Commanders | — | — | — |
| 1981 SB XVI | San Francisco 49ers | — | — | — |
| 1980 SB XV | Las Vegas Raiders | — | — | — |
| 1979 SB XIV | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | — | — |
| 1978 SB XIII | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | — | — |
| 1977 SB XII | Dallas Cowboys | — | — | — |
| 1976 SB XI | Las Vegas Raiders | — | — | — |
| 1975 SB X | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | — | — |
| 1974 SB IX | Pittsburgh Steelers | — | — | — |
| 1973 SB VIII | Miami Dolphins | — | — | — |
| 1972 SB VII | Miami Dolphins | — | — | — |
| 1971 SB VI | Dallas Cowboys | — | — | — |
